Chat vs Comment

2013-07-11 by . 4 comments

Post to Twitter

Hello my friend! How are you doing? It is good to see you around these parts, the Stack Exchange network is a lovely part of the Internet where we can all help each other to learn.

Of course, though, there are rules by which we should abide if we want to keep this place friendly and free of noise. Hey, now, do not look like that. It is true there are many rules, but they are normally quite useful.

Today I want to tell you about how to communicate with your fellow Stack Exchange users. For example: you have seen something someone has written and you disagree. You are a polite person, so you do not think you should just downvote and leave. I admire your style. Communication is good. At Stack Exchange we are allowed to make comments on people’s posts to ask for clarification and to point out mistakes. Obviously we do this in as friendly a way as possible.

Oh? You cannot comment? I see, I see. Do not be troubled. Comments are a privilege, which is earned by attaining 50 reputation points on this site. It is a mere trifle. You will find that by contributing good quality answers and questions you will be there in a few days, maybe even less.

It is important to note that comments are not permanent parts of the site and they get deleted when they outlive their usefulness. Ideally the useful information in a comment will be integrated into the post the comment is on, thus making the comment redundant.

Also, you should understand that the main site is not for discussion. Comments should not be used to discuss a topic at length.

Yes, you are quite right. Sometimes discussion is useful, or necessary. For that there is another place! It is a wonderful place, really. There is much adventure to be had. We call this place chat. The ability to chat is also a privilege, but it has a lower bar. Only 20 reputation points are required.

Chat is used for discussion, yes, but the discussion can roam from being purely about topics on the main site. Many times people wander in with simple questions, questions that might not be suitable for the main site, and ask them in the chat room. This is fine, encouraged even. There is of course a lot of other discussion going on there too, it can get quite frenetic, but do not be afraid to jump in. Be courteous and not pushy and you will be fine.

One excellent trick you can do with chat is to take a discussion in comments and move it to a chat room. This is useful if you think the discussion will become long. Also, if you would like to chat with someone, but they and you are finding the main room too difficult, you can create your own room. The new room will be public, but people generally do not stray from the main room unless they are invited.

Well, my friend, I hope you stay a while. There is a lot you can learn, and maybe a lot you can teach! We will be glad to hear from you.


Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  • Stingos says:

    Hi Matt

    Great post, thanks! If I understand you correctly you are talking about adding “chat” feature to posts/articles as an add on to comments, right? I think it’s a cool feature and I have wandered if you come across a website that offer such capability. Have you ?

  • karampal says:

    Hi friends,As this is my first initiative to improve my english by posting blogs and represent my points. the First topic is chat vs comment . I dont comment normally.but sometimes when i need it,i do.but i know the difference between chat and comments. i think there is huge differecne between chat and comment. first difference in my point of view is that in chatting you normally chat with a single person or in the group of some members.but in comment all the people can participate and see your comment. this topic is like Personal VS Public.

    thats all for today thanks

  • wow…explained well. i usually read aticiles like this. its much informative. being a photographer , i travel along the world , so in my travel these type articles helped me a lot. am working as part of famous photographic company called abu dabhi photography.

  • Leave a comment

    Log in
    with Stack Exchange